Showing posts with label Colleen Doran. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Colleen Doran. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 13, 2013

Colleen Doran: Remastering 'A Distant Soil'

A Distant Soil (Remastered)
by Colleen Doran
(The remastered edition of A Distant Soil Vol 2 ships in December 2013. Order your copy now!)
COLLEEN DORAN:
(from the A Distant Soil blog, 6 November 2013)
Allan Harvey is doing an unmatched job on our restoration. AMAZING work. I have not seen any black and white tone work getting the kind of care and attention we are getting on these volumes! 

Check out this quality! On the right, the source material. On the left, the restoration:

There are other restorations and reprints of black and white comics which use tones, but we have either acquired every single page of original art OR gone into the art, removed the toned areas with very careful digital selections, and then replaced them to match the original tones and tone quality perfectly. No effort has been spared. I have not seen black and white restoration this good anywhere else. All praise to Allan!

Another example: Allan goes in between every single one of these speed lines and carefully removes the tone. This is meticulous work!

The original scan is on the left, and the clean scan is on the right. After cleaning out all the flawed tone, Allan replaces it with a clean digital tone, which you can see in the final, published work. The tone may not look flawed to the naked eye in this shot, but when reduced for print, without this restoration it would create a moire pattern.

Dave Sim is also doing extensive restoration on Cerebus, but he is working from scans without doing the cleanup and replacement of tones we’re doing on A DISTANT SOIL. He has an extensive blog post about the mutual challenges we face HERE. Our solution for A DISTANT SOIL is far more expensive and time consuming, but it yields better results. I sincerely doubt this could be accomplished with the 6000 pages of Cerebus, but we wish Mr Sim the best of luck.

Monday, July 1, 2013

Restoring Black & White Comics: Colleen Doran & Eddie Campbell

A recent post by Dave Sim here on A Moment Of Cerebus describing the difficulties he faces restoring Cerebus Vol 2: High Society seems to have touched a nerve with other comic-book writer/artists faced with the same prospect of reprinting their own artwork from the 1980s and 1990s.

COLLEEN DORAN:
(from the A Distant Soil blog, 19 June 2013)
...I’m sort of appalled at how badly many classic BW comics are reproduced, particularly those which use original hand applied tones. Much of the manga I’ve seen looks pretty awful, especially some of the classic manga I bought more than five years ago. Many publishers just didn’t have access to good scans of higher then 400 dpi. You really need 1200 dpi for this sort of work. In the 1990′s, my printer could not do more than 400, and we opted for photo-reproduction instead. This was the better option for BW printing at the time, but both Sim and I, and a number of other creators, later found ourselves without those negatives. Which was bummerific. This cost me about $20,000 in production work. The restoration, alas, will cost significantly more than that. I hope you’ll take a look at my art sales HERE, and check out this most excellent book sale HERE.

Tone sheets are a unique holdover from the photographic printing process. Art looks better shot from a negative. It’s very tricky to get the pages to look good scanned on computer. But thanks to Allan, the book looks better than it ever could have before. The technology simply wasn’t up to the task 17 years ago. Where flaws showed up in my original tones, I went in and cleaned the pages digitally (or Allan did,) and then I, pixel by pixel, picked out the flaws. This was not funny. 

Anyway, as you can see, getting good quality books to you isn’t just a matter of scanning something and throwing it online, like your random digital pirate. It takes hundreds and hundreds of hours of meticulous labor. The restoration on Volume I of A Distant Soil took four people over 500 hours of work, and that’s just since November. It’ll be out next month! Watch for it!

TOM SPURGEON, THE COMICS REPORTER:
(from The Comics Reporter, 26 June 2013)
...The ability of cartoonists and interested archivists to restore material to publishable form is often assumed, and can be way more difficult than initially realized due to all sorts of reasons including the state of the original art, the ability to get to copies of older art from which newer copies can be derived, and publishing effects that modern publishing techniques are ill-equipped to facilitate. All of these things can result in books that may be impossible to execute to one hundred percent satisfaction, or that merely price themselves beyond the resources of those seeking a new edition.

This isn't a a new thing. For instance, newspaper strip reprints have always had a lot of these problems, or similar ones. There aren't always copies available of every strip that people want to see reprinted, and features that ran in the post-War era were sometimes truncated and have material literally cut out of them on the right side or on the bottom to fit into shrinking places on the comics pages from which copies were clipped and saved. It's frequently a testament to the skill of people that help make these strips available, and the same goes for comic book work like Doran's, that we get a lot of the comics made available to us.

EDDIE CAMPBELL:
(from a comment posted on A Moment Of Cerebus, 26 June 2013)
Hey Dave,
The horrors just came back to me. I went through this with the big Alec book (as you can imagine). On one panel I replaced a wide background screen of tone dot by dot. I zoomed in big on the computer screen and replaced a small area. Once I had a square 16 by 16 i copied and pasted and moved the copy sideways to cover the next 16 by 16, and then I had a big 32 by 32. etc. It was the only way I could think of to do it, and that one panel took a couple of days. I figured it was at least an interesting experiment. In the end I had it down to just four or five places in the whole book that had a moire pattern. When printed, a new one appeared that had been fine in all the proofing. But I was happy with the average in the end.
Best to you, old friend!
Eddie Campbell

Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Colleen Doran: Surviving The Self-Publishing Movement

A Distant Soil by Colleen Doran
(Image / Shadowline, from April 2013)
COLLEEN DORAN:
(from an interview at Comic Book Resources, 8 February 2013)
...after getting battered around by the small press for awhile, I just didn't see why I should sign a contract with another one of these companies. They had no more qualifications than I did, so why should I bother to work with them? I doubted I could screw things up half as much. I spent some time asking around about how to self publish, and Dave Sim was particularly helpful with that. I took the plunge one day, ironically with funds from a legal settlement from one of the small publishers which ripped me off.

Self publishing was a great learning experience. I made very good money for awhile, too. When the distributor system collapsed in the mid-1990s, I took a serious hit, but then I went to Image, thanks to Erik Larsen.

I'm really glad I self published: I learned so much about the business end that I use to this day. I understand discount structures, the importance of getting books done far in advance, trade publishing, a great deal. Real nuts and bolts stuff. I actually learned to appreciate some of my publishing clients more, because I came to understand some of the rules they imposed: they didn't seem so arbitrary.

Self publishing isn't for everybody. It's very labor intensive in ways I don't think anyone who does it really likes. You put a lot of time and effort into packing and shipping product, for example. I'd rather be writing and drawing.

Of course, self publishing on the web is an option that did not exist at the time. You don't have to sink a huge amount of money into printing until you are sure you've actually got an audience to sell it to, which is a huge advantage.

But for print, when I started self publishing, it was a wide open market. There wasn't much competition, certainly not like there is now. It's ridiculous how deluded some people are about their success in the 1980s/1990s. It was a license to print money for awhile. A self published book like mine could sell tens of thousands of copies, more than many mainstream comics do now: it was no big deal.

It got to be a big deal if you held on to your audience after that initial rush. Me, Jeff Smith, Dave Sim, Terry Moore, few people survived. One day, there were a half dozen of us, then there were hundreds. And creators whose books sold tens of thousands saw their sales drop to a few thousand within a decade. It was harsh. I don't think some folks ever quite got over it, or understood what happened.

Anyway, the real test is not how well you do when there's no competition, it's how well you do when there is. No big deal to sell your fantasy comic when there's no alternative. Now there are so many fantasy comics, I can't count them all.

I consider myself lucky, not only to have new readers today, but to have so many readers who stuck with me. I'm very grateful.

After a six-year hiatus, Colleen Doran brings A Distant Soil back to a comic-book store near you via Image Comics/Shadowline with #39 in April 2013. A frontrunner of the '80s indie comics scene, A Distant Soil was more recently derailed by illness and the loss of film negatives. Colleen Doran's sci-fi/adventure series originally broke several barriers both in creation and subject matter. Doran was one of the first women in the indie comics scene to write and draw creator-owned comics and A Distant Soil broke ground by featuring openly gay characters as series stars.

Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Remembering The Self-Publishing Movement

Self-Publishers Limited Edition Print (1993)
Art by Dave Sim, Colleen Doran, James Owen, Martin Wagner & Jeff Smith
JEFF SMITH:
(from 'Remembering The Self-Publishing Movement', February 2008)
...To be honest, I don’t know where the name Self-Publishing Movement came from... but it refers to a distinct period of comics that began in 1993 and went roughly until 1996 or so. Still, having Sim, one of the first, along with Marder, and Veitch, two from the days of the first independents - as well as members of the Creators Rights Summit in the late 80s, I’d say our pedigree was all right. I think at the time we felt like we were part of an ongoing shift in comics that had its distant roots in the American Underground...

COLLEEN DORAN:
(from the Boneville Blog, Part 1 and Part 2, February 2008)
...It all started with a small band of creators who, for the most part, either wouldn’t or couldn’t be published elsewhere. Jeff Smith, knowing nothing about the comics scene, sprang full grown from the head of Zeus. He was The Complete Cartoonist and wowed everybody. Dave Sim was the old man of the group and styled himself The Guru. James Owen was The Salesman. Martin Wagner, The Huckster. Larry Marder, The Machiavellian. Steve Bissette was Mr. Sensitive. Rick Veitch, The Dreamer. Me, I was just The Girl. This wacky crowd of self publishers broke all the rules.

Wild rumors circulated about drug use and romances: I saw none of that. There was no time for goofing around. We worked seven-day weeks, and went for months (or years) without breaks.

At some shows, Dave Sim provided the core self publishers with limo service, as well as other ruffles and flourishes that supported a successful image. All base expenses were our individual responsibility, but limousine service made us look good, and The Guru of self publishing wanted to look good. Making self publishing look good was more important than the objective reality that self publishing was unlikely to be good for almost everyone trying to do it.

When I got home after tooling around in a limo, I didn’t have enough money to buy a car. The public never saw the trips to the Goodwill to buy a decent outfit to wear, anything to save the money to get that next issue published...

...Self publishing was a major source of income for me for nearly six years. But in 1995, the direct comics market imploded and most of the comics distributors went bankrupt. Anyone can self publish on the web now. All of the computer equipment and webspace one might need for a year is roughly the same as the cost of printing one issue of a comic book...

...Cerebus creator Dave Sim (whom I had met after A Distant Soil was first published) and I had several arguments over the possibility of my self publishing, with his view being that I should “Just do it!” and my response “With what money?” falling on deaf ears. We parted ways and didn’t speak for years while I planned to publish my way. I drew more comics for Marvel and DC, and with the settlement money from one of my publishers over rights to A Distant Soil combined with a small loan, I finally had enough cash to get my A Distant Soil comic printed myself...

Colleen Doran is the writer/artist of the fantasy series A Distant Soil and illustrator of many other comics and graphic novels. Please support Colleen's restoration project to complete 'A Distant Soil'.

Colleen Doran In Photos

Dave Sim, Martin Wagner, James Owen & Colleen Doran
Capital City Trade Show 1993
Backcover, Cerebus #174 (September 1993)
(Photo by John Judge, River City Comics)

Dave Sim,  Jeff Smith, James Owen, Neil Gaiman & Colleen Doran circa 1994
(Photo courtesy of Colleen Doran)

Revenge Photo: The Real Colleen Doran
Backcover, Cerebus #175 (October 1993)
(Photo by Dave Sim)

Colleen Doran is the writer/artist of the fantasy series A Distant Soil and illustrator of many other comics and graphic novels. Please support Colleen's restoration project to complete 'A Distant Soil'.

Tuesday, December 4, 2012

Colleen Doran: 'High Society Digital' Review

COLLEEN DORAN:
(from Colleen's blog at A Distant Soil, 7 June 2012)
Some cool projects you should check out... Dave Sim brings his groundbreaking comic Cerebus back to life with a new digital series packed with amazing extras. This is a very smart and successful Kickstarter campaign, already well past its goal. It doesn't need any more support from me, but that is not the point. Cerebus was the most important book of the self publishing movement, and Dave Sim is the single most important person in the history of the creator rights movement. Everybody else who contributed is much appreciated, but no one was a more outspoken - or original - advocate.

Colleen Doran is the writer/artist of the fantasy series A Distant Soil and illustrator of many other comics and graphic novels. Please support Colleen's restoration project to complete 'A Distant Soil'.

Monday, December 3, 2012

Meeting Jack Kirby

1981 Chicago Comicon:
L to R: Julie Schwartz, Colleen Doran, Jack Kirby, Dave Sim
DAVE SIM:
(from the 'Virtual Kirby Panel', The Jack Kirby Collector #27, February 2000)
Okay, before I go, I have to tell you about meeting Jack Kirby at the 1981 Chicago Comicon - I think it was 1981. I was sitting with Bill Sienkiewicz by the pool at this party and I saw Jack Kirby a dozen yards away or so on the other side of a bunch of table and chairs. Bill says to me, "Have you met Kirby?" And I say "No, but I'd sure like to." And Bill says, "Well, come on - I'll introduce you." So we're moving aside the chairs which are sort of jumbled together and making some progress to where Jack is standing and I hear off to one side somebody yelling "Jack! Jack!" which Kirby doesn't hear. I look over and I see Julie Schwartz, and he's got his arm around Colleen Doran (who is like 12 in 1981 - I'm kidding, I think she was 19 or something) in that Julie Schwartz way of his that, for reasons I've never been able to fathom, some feminists like Cat Yronwode find really endearing and other feminists like Colleen Doran find really creepy, and he's bringing her over to meet Jack Kirby. So. It turns into this really strange kind of footrace with Bill and I moving all of these chairs out of our way and Julie Schwartz and Colleen moving the chairs out of their way and I'm thinking, "I have got to get their before Colleen does or I'll never meet Kirby" (because Jack Kirby, whatever you might have heard, was flesh-and-blood and a manly guy and Colleen was about the cutest little thing you ever laid eyes on when she was 19 - not that she isn't now - and from my own experience I have to tell you that if one guy that I know is bringing another guy to meet me at a con and another guy I know is bringing a nineteen-year-old girl to meet me, I can tell you who is going to get the lion's share of the attention and for that I don't apologise one bit). So Julie is going "Jack! Jack!" and just as Bill and I get there, Kirby hears him and he turns that way and Julie pushes Colleen towards him and says, "Jack, I'd like you to meet this lovely goil" (Julie Schwatrz is the only New Yorker I know who actually pronounces it that way) "this lovely young goil, Colleen." And Colleen was charming and starstruck and Kirby was charming and grinning from ear-to-ear and I'm standing behind Bill thinking, "Oh well," but still pretty jazzed that Jack Kirby is only two feet away and that was pretty amazing in itself, let me tell you - and I'm watching Jack Kirby talking to Colleen when suddenly Bill lunges forward and says, "Jack! I'd like you to meet Dave Sim!" And Jack says, "I admire your philosophy." To which I said something like "Abth dahbt bladda thadda thut" and Julie - like any good poker player who knows he has a winning hand - suggests that Bill take a picture of Julie and Jack and "this lovely goil, Colleen." Well, Bill pushed me into the picture, flash. Julie edged me out of the picture and I sort of staggered away leaving Kirby to enjoy the rest of his chat with Julie and the "lovely goil."

Philosophy? Philosophy?

I puzzled over that one for a while and then I remembered that the Comics Journal had just published a piece of mine called "A Declaration Of Independence," which was to be one of a series of pieces by various publishers about their ideas on publishing comic books (or, in my case, a comic book). I had talked about as much as I thought I dare to for a punk kid who had only been in the business for a few years about Kirby's situation at Marvel and what I saw as the origins of the unfair treatment he got. Anyway, it was very reassuring to find out that he had read it and not thought that I didn't know my place. And then to find out that he admired it - well, wow!

Jack Kirby (1917-1994), with writer-editor Stan Lee, co-created many of Marvel Comics' major characters in the 1960s, including the Fantastic Four, the X-Men and the Hulk. Kirby left Marvel in 1970 for rival DC, where he created his Fourth World saga.

Julie Schwartz (1915-2004) was long-time editor at DC Comics, where he was primary editor over the company's flagship superheroes, Superman and Batman. He was inducted into the comics industry's Jack Kirby Hall of Fame in 1996 and the Will Eisner Comic Book Hall of Fame in 1997. 

Bill Sienkiewicz is the Eisner Award-winning American artist and writer best known for Moon Knight, New Mutants, Stray Toasters and Elektra: Assassin.  

Colleen Doran is the writer/artist of the fantasy series A Distant Soil and illustrator of many other comics and graphic novels. Please support Colleen's restoration project to complete 'A Distant Soil'.

Sunday, December 2, 2012

Dave Sim: Thoughts About Colleen

The Applicant (Cerebus #91, October 1986)
Art by Colleen Doran, Dave Sim & Gerhard
DAVE SIM:
As Neal Adams said of Stan Drake -- he knew how to put expressions on girls' faces and they would still look pretty. Colleen has also had that remarkable skill, which was a big reason that I asked her to tight pencil the unnamed Colleen clone in The Applicant over my layouts. The emotion -- complete rage -- was there in the text and I just did very rough faces and figures. Sure enough, the tight pencils came back -- COMPLETE rage -- but still cute as a button. Inking those faces was both a pleasure and an education in pencilling female characters that came in very handy, particularly on JAKA'S STORY.

Colleen seemed to me to be a natural for self-publishing. She certainly had the sales figures on A DISTANT SOIL to sustain a regular title. And as Larry David and Jerry Seinfeld concluded about the pre-Elaine SEINFELD scripts: 'This show needs some estrogen'. That was -- and is -- certainly true of self-publishing. Elaine always reminded me of Colleen. When she did make the leap to self-publishing, joining me and Martin Wagner of HEPCATS, I made a point of the three of us going out for dinner with Colleen's Mom. 'There's no way to EXPLAIN Colleen -- better to just let Martin experience her for himself.' He spent the whole dinner sitting there with his mouth open, looking back and forth between Colleen and her Mom and me. He adjusted beautifully.

Of course, Colleen ultimately opted for the mainstream success that is so justifiably hers and 'co-publishing' with Erik Larsen's Image studio. In retrospect, sticking with self-publishing would have constituted hiding a very bright light under a very small bushel.

I would certainly encourage any CEREBUS fans with a few dollars to throw around to visit Colleen's website and buy a 'Colleen Collectible' or two to help finance the mammoth project of reconstructing all of the material she's now missing as a results of her printer ditching her negatives. I mean, don't forget about CEREBUS, but let's make sure that Colleen is in good shape to cross the A DISTANT SOIL finish line!

Colleen Doran: 'A Distant Soil' Restoration Project

Loss of Negatives:
Our printer went bankrupt and accidentally discarded our complete inventory of negatives of the art for my entire A Distant Soil graphic novel series, nearly 1000 pages of material. While we do have a good deal of the art, restoring the lost pages is taking five months, and the loss of the negatives has cost me over $20,000 in production work. We cannot bring my series back into print without this restoration.

We're deeply in the middle of the restoration now. It is going very well, but the primary concern is funds to pay my assistant, who is doing the bulk of restoration on original art we were unable to recover. In the end, it appears we will be able to restore the vast majority of the series directly from the original art. But the few hundred pages of art that must be restored from copies are quite the challenge. Mr Allan Harvey is handling that job, and he is doing great. I am handling the 700 or so pages of original artwork. 

Original Art Search:
If you purchased A Distant Soil original art, I would be very grateful if you would get in touch with me. I would be especially grateful if you would either scan the art to my specs, or loan me the originals for scanning. I will reimburse you all your expenses, as well as send you a little something nice extra. (At first I thought I only needed pages sold prior to 2008, but some of my early scans are quite poor. So, no matter what you have bought, please let me know.) 

Final Story Arc Due In 2013:
I have twelve issues of new art and story to complete to bring the A Distant Soil series to its finale at Image Comics beginning next year. This is the end run of my epic series, and I’ve got to do it right.  There is a lot of planning to do - financial planning as well as scheduling - and technical work that must be completed on the new editions of the graphic novels.

Please help Colleen Doran complete the 'A Distant Soil' restoration project.